's beauty must-haves are as low-key as she seems to be. "I have them all in my purse," she told PEOPLE in New York recently.
Such as? "I love the [Neutrogena] 'MoistureShine' lip gloss," the Neutrogena spokesperson admitted. "We always use them on our cheeks, too - especially when we carry around bags the size that we do where you can fit like one lip gloss in there."
Makeup aside, Panettiere is currently focused on ...